Consequences
As many of you who read this blog know, staying up until and often through the wee hours of the morning is not exactly a rare occurrence for me. It has been awhile, though, since I have done so because I've simply been plagued with too much regret and guilt to get any sleep. It's one of those nights that, even if I could sleep, I wouldn't; I don't feel that I deserve it.
To those Australians who have been cunning enough to find the location of this blog, a few of you in particular - and you know who you are - would really do best not to read further. And that's not a cute gimmick. That's not a subtle way to entice you to read further. It's a warning. No; it's a plea. Maybe it's both. I urge you to read no further. If you must, it is at your own risk; I write this blog as if no one reads it, and I refuse to edit myself just because I know that some do. I will not be held responsible for whatever feelings you may be left with afterward.
I had intended not to blog this at all. I thought it would have to go unspoken. But it has become clear to me now that events have gone in such a way that the situation is already irreparable. In which case, if those who have been warned not to continue on are doing so, this is my chance to tell my side of the story.
I am quite sure that I have mentioned my good Australian friends James and Emma many, many times in this blog. In the 6 months I've known them, they have become a daily part of my life. They have become as constant as the sun and the moon and, like those celestial bodies, are a very good pair. I do not say this lightly; they have become family to me. But anyway, here is my story. I'll just tell it best I can, and I'll let the chips fall where they may.
I suppose this really began the morning after my birthday. James and Emma had a fight after we were all done hanging out. According to her testimony of it, he felt that she hadn't paid him enough attention or made sure he was properly taken care of. I disagreed on this point; I felt that she had done her due diligence, but then, it's not really my business. Emma came to visit me in my room. This is not something that she does terribly often. As a matter of fact, I can remember only two such previous occasions, the details of which are not necessarily relevant to this discussion. She just needed to talk it out. We talked; I gave her a hug; she felt better and, for some reason or another went off to visit Rowie.
The story I got from her about that is she talked with Rowie, they drunkenly passed on on his bed, and in the morning, they awoke cuddling - thinking each other were different people - and kissed. She told me they realized almost immediately what was happening, stopped, and said their clumsy goodbyes. I figured that it was nothing to bother James about . . . she had come dangerously close to making a mistake, but in the end had done the right thing and did not make one. And she seemed to feel genuine regret about the situation. This was all on Thursday the 12th.
Sometime on the evening of Saturday, October the 14th, she came to visit me again. She needed to talk about James. Apparently, they were having some more rough patches in their relationship, and she just needed to talk it out.
Now, this could potentially be an awkward position for me. They're both my friends. Equally. They got back together about a week after I first met James, so I can't really play favorites when it comes to them. But I figured offering a friendly ear and some kind words weren't against the rules of being neutral. She was feeling a bit trapped; from her perspective, she felt that James could be a bit controlling and smothering, and it's fair to say he got jealous of her giving attention to other guys. She told me a great deal about their storied history (which I will not repeat out of reverence - let it suffice to say that getting back together was a leap of faith on his part) and, in such context, while I cannot really condone his behavior, I can certainly understand it. James was beginning to unwittingly help to create the very situation he was afraid of happening by holding the reins too tightly. Of course, as I told her, the way that she chooses to react to that behavior is a choice that is left to her and to her alone. I told her she was responsible for those choices and the consequences.
I could sympathize with both of their positions, really. I know what it's like to be her, and be in a relationship where you feel like you don't have any room to breathe. She had to sneak off to come and talk to me because she felt that James wouldn't understand, for example. It's just not necessarily a fun way to live. For James' part, I also know how he could completely misinterpret things. He felt like he was just being a really loving - if slightly paranoid - boyfriend, and just couldn't fathom why she would want or need some time apart from him now and again.
Part of the problem was that Emma is a lot like me in that she doesn't like confrontation. They'd get in a fight over James considering that she was spending too much time talking to me or some other thing and she'd back down and concede his point even when she didn't agree with it. I know from experience that strategy is a dead end road. Every time you back down, every time you concede to a point, every time you don't stand up for yourself, you give away a part of yourself. Eventually one of two things happen, depending on personality. Either the person just finds they have nothing left to give and the relationship withers away, or the person will suddenly explode in a fit of rage and things will end quickly and violently.
I wanted neither of these things to happen to my two dear friends. I wanted them to resolve their differences and become impassioned lovers again. I have envisioned them seeing me off at the airport together. And I wanted to help keep that a reality. I told her most of what I've said above, and I told her that she needs to learn to stand up for herself in a fight. She said that James would always get very hurt when she would, and I told her that, again, him reacting that way is his choice. Whether consciously or not, that reaction is designed to keep her from fighting back, and the more he knows it works, the more he'll do it. Stand up for yourself; if you don't think you've done anything wrong, don't concede that you have. I cautioned that she shouldn't be a bitch about it, but calmly and assuredly just say what she feels is right and meet a compromise with him like civilized people.
This is advice I would've given anybody in their situation and, as such, I felt no qualms about giving said advice. I made no judgements about James nor Emma, just gave sound advice. It was up to her to do what she would with it. She thanked me for listening and left.
She came back about a half an hour later. This time, she was fairly distraught and a bit hysterical. She told me that when she got back, James had felt that she had been gone doing whatever it is that she was doing for too long. That he had stopped what he was doing and sat in the dark waiting for her to come back and pounced on her the moment she came back after exactly an hour and 10 minutes (apparently he counted) and wanted to know what she'd been up to. Unfortunately for me, she decided to take my advice and she stood up for herself. She said that James did not react to this well at all and . . . I'm a little hazy on this part, but apparently she either left or James threw her out or some such thing . . . but either way she ended up at my room and clearly needed a friend and a bit of asylum while she composed herself and collected her thoughts.
This was definitely getting into more ethically ambiguous territory, seeing as James would clearly not approve of her running to me, but what was I to do? Turn her aside? Feed her to the dogs? Of course not. I'm too good a person for my own good to do that. I figured I'd let her vent, then send her on her way, either home or to resolve the situation with James . . . whatever she decided to do.
Then James IMs me on MSN. He wants to know where Emma is. . . . What do I do? Given that Emma has run to me for protection and is sitting in my room scared and hysterical, I have to admit that my feelings on this matter are beginning to get a little biased. It's not that I'm judging James or think he's a bad person, but clearly Emma needed a friend and a place to wait it out while James cooled down. And frankly, she found me first. But I've got this choice, now. I either tell him that she is here and basically feed one of my best friends to the hounds while simultaneously feeding the fire, or I flat out lie to one of my other best friends. Being the diplomat that I am, I chose my words very carefully and said exactly this: "She stopped by - why, what's up?"
Taken literally . . . it isn't a denial of her whereabouts, but neither is it an affirmation. Granted, it was designed to deceive him a little, and to make him infer that she was here but is no longer. Basically, I felt that he did have the right to know that she was here at some point. So I gave him that bone. They could work that out on their own. I also felt that she had the right to ask for some asylum. So I tried to do that in the same breath. I figured this would give her a bit of time to finish composing herself, then I'd send her on her way.
The next pitch comes at me like a Pedro Martinez change-up. There's a knock at my door. Emma and I exchange knowing looks. It's going to be James. I open the door . . . and sure enough there he stands. This is the part that absolutely breaks my heart; he hasn't come looking for Emma. He's come for the same purpose that Emma originally came: he needed to talk. I am Jack's deep sense of despair. I can only imagine the thoughts that went through his mind when he turned his head and discovered Emma sitting on the bed. I can only also imagine the betrayal he must have felt. I could also see the raw fear in Emma's eyes. I have never been so torn in my life.
Even in hindsight I'm still not sure what the right choice would have been. Is there one? I don't think so. It's not a black and white situation. It was a difficult decision . . . and I made it as best I could.
They both stormed out, yelling and screaming at each other. About a minute later Emma comes back in through the outside door with tears in her eyes. She tells me he broke up with her and that it's over, grabs her purse, and leaves.
I. Feel. . . . Indescribably bad. I really don't have anything to feel guilty about. I'm a victim of circumstance. These are the things I keep telling myself to remind myself. But still, I feel guilty. Emma talks to me via MSN on her mobile while she wanders around in the parking lot in the dark. I think of telling her she ought to come back here, but I don't. It's my first instinct because I want to offer some comfort to someone for my part in this cruel happenstance, and James certainly won't be talking to me for awhile. But I don't make the suggestion. It's the wrong play. She shouldn't be here. Especially not if James decided to come back over. She almost did. Given the choice between having her wander the parking lot at 2am or come back to my room, as a gentleman, the choice is obvious. I was very nervous about that possibility, though. I steeled my resolve against a possible advance in her emotional state. She had thanked me and told me how appreciative she was of my help a few too many times and had openly admitted she needed some attention and affection.
And, let's face it. I'm not attracted to Emma in that way at all . . . but after that whole Grace thing, and after not having a date in almost 2 years and not having had sex in the same amount of time . . . any possible affection from any decently attractive woman is going to be a source of temptation for me. I wasn't presuming anything, I was simply preparing for the worst; there was no fucking way I was going to do anything to hurt James anymore than I already had.
Eventually she went home. I sighed a big sigh of relief that she made the right decision. She IMed me from there and we talked a bit. And she wanted to call. But then, suddenly, she told me she was coming back to Chisholm to talk to Rowie. I was very confused by this. And very against the idea. It was a BAD play, especially given that Rowie and James live one floor apart, and that Rowie and James have some history vis a vis Ashy. (The short version is Ashy and Rowie dated for a long time and Ashy fooled around a bit with James both during and after the relationship.) She told me she just needed some closure, and she needed to find out exactly what that kiss meant.
I ought to have convinced her not to go over. I should have fucking barricaded the tower 1 door and not let her go in. But I didn't. And, in the same night that her and James break up, she brings the crazy love circus by spending the night and most of the day with Rowie. I found out about that the next day when she PM'd me . . . from Rowie's computer and screen name. I was just . . . floored. First of all, something about it REALLY bothered me. It just didn't seem right. Honestly, I felt a little used. Not that getting the girl was even on my list of things to do, but it left me feeling fairly raw that I did all that leg work and get nothing for it in return but grief only to have her do something so fucking stupid like sleep with the guy James already has a history with within a few hours of breaking up with him.
Again, I'm pissed at myself for what I didn't do. I should've told her that she was crazy and to get the hell out of dodge. Now. If she absolutely had to spend time with Rowie, fucking get off campus. She had an apartment, take him there. Whatever. Just make yourself invisible. Don't goddamn hang out 1 floor down from James, especially since she reported that he hit her when she went up there earlier in the day to return his stuff.
I was just bewildered and very very angry with all three of them to think straight enough to tell her anything useful. What she did was NOT right and I can't condone it at all, but I can understand it. It's a case of heartbreak and misplaced emotion and a subconscious need for revenge. I was also not very happy at all with James. Hitting a woman is a VERY big no-no in my book. That shit is just not called for. But mostly, I was beyond furious with Rowie. While one could argue that Emma may or may not have known what she was doing . . . Rowie certainly knew exactly what he was doing. It was his chance for revenge against James for the Ashy situation. I found that so despicable I almost vomited.
Believe it or not, this gets worse. Later that Sunday evening there's a knock at my door. It's a very drunk and clearly very angry James. Harsh and Dave are with him, clearly there just in case he decides to do anything stupid. He asks if I know where Emma is. At this point, it's been about two hours since I've talked to her. I had hoped she was smart enough to leave by now, and had pretty much assumed she had since I was getting no responses to my PMs. That . . . and he clearly did not need to hear the truth about where she was right that second. Seriously, the poor guy was about *this* close from snapping. This time, I was protecting him if anyone at all. I told him that, at this very moment, I honestly didn't know where she was. I had a sinking feeling she was still at Rowie's . . . but I didn't dare make that conjecture. He asked to check my room and kitchen. I graciously obliged him. I seriously felt like a pile of shit.
As soon as he was satisfied, he left. I immediately IM'd Rowie/Emma and told them what James was like and that he was looking for Emma. I knew that Rowie's would be his next stop. But they never got the warning. Rowie IM'd me back a bit afterward and told me that James came in and found them both in the room. He hit them both and began to chase after Emma before Dave could wrestle him to the ground.
I was . . . in awe, to say the least. I couldn't believe that it had come to this in less than 24 hours since she first came to me to talk. That deep-seated feeling of unattachable guilt kept creeping deeper and deeper into my stomach. Emma called me later and told me she was afraid . . . and I can imagine so. His actions were despicable . . . but his feelings were justified. As diplomatically as possible I let her know that I felt what happened was her own fault for being stupid enough to not only sleep with Rowie, but literally be a sitting duck and just wait for James to catch her red-handed.
Dave came over and he and I talked and got things about the situation off of our chests until about 3:30 in the morning. Just before he left, my MSN tells me that James had signed in. He had blocked me up until that point. After he left, he asked me a series of questions. Mostly what I knew and why I didn't tell him what I knew. And he asked if I kissed Emma. I told him the truth about everything, and was quite happy to say that I did nothing ungentlemanly with Emma; that's not how I roll.
He then told me his side of the story. He told me that he found out from whomever (I assume Rowie) that, on Thursday morning, she didn't stop. And there were some other things. And he was angry at me for not telling him what I knew. I tried to explain that I only knew what she told me and I had believed her and didn't think it was anything that I needed to get involved in. But he wouldn't hear of it. He's moving out of Chisholm and back home either today or tomorrow, and will return to uni this semester only to turn in his final projects during finals. He bid me a good life, and seemed very hurt. I have now lost a friend because of all this.
Needless to say, I got no sleep last night. And I'm very hurt and confused. Either James or Emma is lying to me and trying to turn me against the other, as their stories greatly contradict. I honestly don't want to know who it is. There have been too many casualties already. James has disowned me, Rowie I am just disgusted with, and now it seems Emma I can't completely trust. But I'd like to retain Emma as a friend, if only because losing two out of this whole situation is two too many.
It's after a few weeks like the ones I've had that I come back to a question that I ask myself occasionally: Why am I who I am? Why do I stick my neck out for my friends like I do? Even when I get nothing in return and, in fact, often get shit in return? Life would be so much more personally rewarding if I was just a self-centered, misogynistic, womanizing asshole. And then, I remember the answer. It's because I don't do it for me. The purpose of being selfless - in fact, the definition - is to do things for the benefit of others at a sacrifice to yourself. It's the knowing I've helped someone else that brings the reward.
So maybe I'll help Emma. I'll help her learn from what she's done and maybe help her become a stronger and better person. Maybe. It's at least something positive I can take from this.
Aussie Doozie of the Day:
What, that wasn't enough? Fuck off.


